| Age | Commit message (Collapse) | Author |
|---|
|
|
|
Before this change, global shader parameters were represented in the IR as just being ordinary global variables.
The only indication that a particular global represented a parameter was when it got a layotu attached to it (as part of back-end processing), and we've had a number of bugs related to layouts being dropped so that what should have been a shader parameter turned into an ordinary global variable in the output.
This change is more strongly motivated by the fact that making shader parameters look like globals means that we cannot easily reason about their value when doing IR transformations.
If we see two `load`s from the same global variable can we assume they yield the same value?
In the general case we cannot, and this means that any transformation that wants to rely on the fact that an input `Texture2D` shader parameter can't actually change over the life of the program needs to do extra work.
The fix here is to introduce a new kind of IR instruction that represents a global shader parameter directly (not a pointer to it as a global would), at which point there isn't even such a notion as a "load" from the parameter, since it represents the value directly.
In several cases logic that used to apply to global variables in case they were shader parameters (by looking for a layout) is now moved to apply to these global parameters.
The biggest source of issues in this change was that switching from pointers to plain values to represent these shader parameters stresses different cases in type legalization. I also had to deal with the case of legalization for GLSL where we actually *do* need global shader parameters that are writable (since varying output goes in the global scope), but in that case I borrowed the use of pointer-like `Out<...>` and `InOut<...>` types to represent that intent, which we were already using for function parameters representing outputs.
A few tests started failing because the changes lead to a slightly different order of code emission, which in some HLSL tests resulted in a function parameter named `s` getting emitted before a global parameter named `s`, leading to the latter getting the name `s_1` instead of `s_0`.
A few SPIR-V tests started failing because the new approach means that we no longer end up performing a load from all varying input parameters at the start of `main` and instead reference the varying inputs directly. The resulting code is more idomatic, but it differed from the baselines for those tests.
|
|
* Rework command-line options handling for entry points and targets
Overview:
* The biggest functionality change is that the implicit ordering constraints when multiple `-entry` options are reversed: any `-stage` option affects the `-entry` to its *left* instead of to its *right* as it used to. This is technically a breaking change, but I expect most users aren't using this feature.
* The options parsing tries to handle profile versions and stages as distinct data (rather than using the combined `Profile` type all over), and treats a `-profile` option that specifies both a profile version and a stage (e.g., `-profile ps_5_0`) as if it were sugar for both a `-profile` and a `-stage` (e.g., `-profile sm_5_0 -stage fragment`).
* We now technically handle multiple `-target` options in one invocation of `-slangc`, but do not advertise that fact in the documentation because it might be confusing for users. Similar to the relationship between `-stage` and `-entry`, any `-profile` option affects the most recent `-target` option unless there is only one `-target`.
* The logic for associating `-o` options with corresponding entry points and targets has been beefed up. The rule is that a `-o` option for a compiled kernel binds to the entry point to its left, unless there is only one entry point (just like for `-stage`). The associated target for a `-o` option is found via a search, however, because otherwise it would be impossible to specify `-o` options for both SPIR-V and DXIL in one pass.
* The handling of output paths for entry points in the internal compiler structures was changed, because previously it could only handle one output path per entry point (even when there are multiple targets). The new logic builds up a per-target mapping from an entry point to its desired output path (if any).
Details:
* Support for formatting profile versions, stages, and compile targets (formats) was added to diagnostic printing, so that we can make better error messages. This is fairly ad hoc, and it would be nice to have all of the string<->enum stuff be more data-driven throughout the codebase.
* Test cases were added for (almost) all of the error conditions in the current options validation. The main one that is missing is around specifying an `-entry` option before any source file when compiling multiple files. This is because the test runner is putting the source file name first on the command line automatically, so we can't reproduce that case.
* Several reflection-related tests now reflect entry points where they didn't before, because the logic for detecting when to infer a default `main` entry point have been made more loose
* On the dxc path, beefed up the handling of mapping from Slang `Profile`s to the coresponding string to use when invoking dxc.
* A bunch of tests cases were in violation of the newly imposed rules, so those needed to be cleaned up.
* There were also a bunch of test cases that had accidentally gotten "disabled" at some point because there were comparing output from `slangc` both with and without a `-pass-through` option, but that meant that any errors in command-line parsing produced the *same* error output in both the Slang and pass-through cases. This change updates `slang-test` to always expect a successful run for these tests, and then manually updates or disables the various test cases that are affected.
* When merging the updated test for matrix layout mode, I found that the new command-line logic was failing to propagate a matrix layout mode passed to `render-test` into the compiler. This was because the `-matrix-layout*` options were implemented as per-target, but the target was being set by API while the option came in via command line (passed through the API). It seems like we want matrix layout mode to be a global option anyway (rather than per-target), so I made that change here.
* Add missing expected output files
* A 64-bit fix
* Remove commented-out code noted in review
|
|
The basic idea here is that when lowering to the IR, the front-end will attach a "name hint" to the IR instruction(s) that represent a given declaration, and then the passes that work on the IR will try to preserve and propagate those names, and then finally the emit logic will use them in place of mangled or unique names when available.
This change does *not* try to deal with the issues that arise when we try to use those variable names in the output without any modification (e.g., handling cases where they might clash with keywords or builtins in the target language). Instead, it tries to establish baseline behavior for propagating through names, so that a later change can concentrate on the issue of using those names exactly when it is legal to do so.
In order to avoid issues around the name "hints" causing problems we take two main steps:
1. We "scrub" each name to reduce it down to the allowed set of identifier characters in C-like languages, and then ensure that it doesn't do things that would be illegal in some downstream languages (e.g., consecutive underscores are not allowed in GLSL) or could clash with Slang's mangled names. This process isn't guaranteed to give distinct results for distinct inputs (it isn't a mangling scheme, after all).
2. We generate a unique ID for each occurence of a given name and always use that as a suffix. This means that even if a name happens to overlap with a keyword (if you somehow have a variable named `do`), we will still add a suffix that makes it not a problem (we'd output `do_0` which is fine).
The logic for generating these names is mostly straightforward. For simple variables, we use their given name directly, while for other declarations we try to form a name that includes their parent declaration (e.g. `SomeType.someMethod`).
Various IR passes need to propagate or preserve this information. The most interesting is type legalization, when we take a variable with an aggregate type and split some of the fields out into their own variables. In that case we generate "dotted" names like `someVar.someTexture` and rely on the emit logic to turn that into `someVar_someTexture`.
During SSA generation, if we are promoting a variable to SSA temporaries, we will try to propagate the name of the variable over to the temporaries (unless they already have a name from some other place). The same applies to block parameters ("phi nodes").
Many of the test changes need their expected output to be updated for this change. Luckily in most cases the output has gotten easier to understand.
|
|
* Introduce an IR-level type system
Up to this point, the Slang IR has used the front-end type system to represent types in the IR.
As a result (but ultimately more importantly) the IR representation of generics and specialization has used AST-level concepts embedded in the IR.
For example, to express the specialization of `vector<T,N>` to a concrete type `float` for `T`, we needed an IR operation that could represent the specialization, with operands that somehow represented the type argument `float`.
The whole thing was very complicated.
The big idea of this change is to introduce a new representation in which types in the IR are just ordinary instructions, so that using them as operands makes sense. The hierarchy of IR types closely mirrors the AST-side hierarchy for now, and that will probably be something we should maintain going forward.
In order to make these changes work, though, I also had to do major overhauls of things like the way substitutions are performed, how we check interface conformances, the way lookup through interface types is done, etc. etc. This is a big change, and unfortunately any attempt to summarize it in the commit message wouldn't do it justice.
* Fix 64-bit build warning
* Fix up some clang warnings/errors
|
|
The basic change is simple: remove support for all code generation paths other than the IR.
There is a lot of vestigial code left, but the main logic in `ast-legalize.*` is gone.
Doing this breaks a *lot* of tests, for various reasons:
- We can no longer guarantee exactly matching DXBC or SPIR-V output after things pass through out IR
- Many builtins don't have matching versions defined for GLSL output via IR (even when they had versions defined via the earlier approach that worked with the AST)
- A lot of code creates intermediate values of opaque types in the IR, which turn into opaque-type temporaries that aren't allowed (this breaks many GLSL tests, but also some HLSL)
I implemented some small fixes for issues that I could get working in the time I had, but most of the above are larger than made sense to fix in this commit.
For now I'm disabling the tests that cause problems, but we will need to make a concerted effort to get things working on this new substrate if we are going to make good on our goals.
|
|
Should fix #351
The basic problem is that the type layout logic in Slang isn't taking into account the way that resource-type fields in aggregate types get split. When you just have a bare aggregate, this oversight doesn't cause a problem, but once you put those aggregates into an array, the problems become clear.
Given:
```hlsl
struct Test
{
Texture2D a;
Texture2D b;
};
Test test[8];
```
The default type-layout algorithm gives `Test::a` an offset of zero, and `Test::b` an offset of one.
However, after splitting, we have something like:
```hlsl
Texture2D test_a[8];
Texture2D test_b[8];
```
It is clear in this case that `test_b` can't start at an offset of one relative to `test_a` - it needs to start at `register(t8)`.
This change handles things by adjusting the layout of an array type to account for this detail as soon as it is created. The alternative would have been to not change layout rules at all, but to instead try to adjust things at the point where types get split (and the layout for the un-split case gets applied to the split variable). The reason for doing it the way it is in this change is that the reflection API will hopefully provide accurate information.
Related to reflection information, one thing that is missing here is proper computation of the "stride" for an array like this. We'll see if that needs to be addressed in a follow-up.
|
